Home›Support›Knowledge Base›Architecture Choice
Architecture Choice

HDBaseT or AV-over-IP — choosing the transport for the installation

Both transports move uncompressed or near-uncompressed video across a building. They solve different problems. Choosing between them at design time — rather than discovering the constraint at commissioning — is one of the highest-leverage decisions a specifier makes.

ARCHITECTURE

HDBaseT: deterministic, bounded, simple

HDBaseT carries video, audio, USB, control, and power over a single CAT cable, point to point, at a fixed distance budget. The signal path is a wire. Latency is a known quantity measured in sub-frame terms. There is no network to configure, no switch to qualify, and no multicast to reason about.

It suits installations with a countable number of endpoints, where the topology is stable and the run lengths sit inside the specification. A boardroom, a lecture theatre, a courtroom. Where the matrix is central and the displays are known, HDBaseT is the lower-risk, lower-cost architecture.

AV-over-IP: elastic, scalable, network-dependent

AV-over-IP encapsulates the signal and transports it across standard network infrastructure. Any endpoint can reach any other endpoint. Adding a display means adding a receiver and a switch port, not re-engineering a matrix.

That elasticity carries a requirement: the network must be designed for it. Multicast forwarding, IGMP snooping, adequate switch backplane, and — for uncompressed 10G transport — the correct optics or copper. When those conditions are met, the architecture scales past any matrix.

The transport tiers, and what each trades

The announced TELECIS SDVoE tier targets 10 Gigabit for uncompressed, sub-frame-latency distribution where every original bit must arrive. It is the correct choice for medical, broadcast, and command environments.

JPEG2000 over 1 Gigabit is visually lossless and runs on standard gigabit infrastructure. It is the balanced tier for enterprise and campus, where the network already exists and the budget is finite.

A decision, in three questions

How many endpoints will exist in five years? Under roughly sixteen and stable, HDBaseT. Growing, or spanning buildings, AV-over-IP.

Who owns the network? Where the AV integrator controls the switch, AV-over-IP is straightforward. Where IT owns it, the conversation must happen at design time.

What is the latency tolerance? Interactive KVM and live production demand the lowest, most predictable latency the budget allows — uncompressed, or visually lossless intra-frame at 1G. Signage and overflow accept compression happily.

CriterionHDBaseTAV-over-IP
Endpoint countBounded by matrix size — to 8×8 in the current range, with 16×16 announcedBounded by switch ports and uplinks
LatencySub-frame, fixedSet by the codec tier — sub-frame uncompressed, low-latency intra-frame JPEG2000
InfrastructureDirect CAT runs; no network dependencyA managed, multicast-ready network
ScalingReplace or expand the matrixAdd an endpoint and a switch port
Best forStable rooms, known topology, contained budgetsGrowing estates, multiple buildings, any-to-any routing
REF
Referenced in this article

Specified as a system.

Specifying for a project?

Specifying with this in mind?

Send the room and the constraints. We return the architecture, the bill of materials, and the route to supply.